I want to thank everyone who responded to my story about being rescued from the bleak streets of London on a Saturday evening with their comments, thoughts and suggestions about what might have been the Mussar lesson for me in that trying situation. I’ve thought about it more, and reflected on the suggestions, and have come up with an understanding that I want to share.
As soon as I accepted that the lock would not open and the people inside who had double locked the door would not respond to my pounding on the door, I had the thought that this was a moment when I needed to put my trust in God (bitachon). I had made my effort (my hishtadlut) by trying the code in the pin pad multiple times, and by hammering on the door so insistently that it attracted the attention of passers-by. It was not that there was not more that I could do – as proved to be the case – but I didn’t even think that I needed to invoke my middah of trust until I had done the two obvious things that I had in my hands to do: punch in the code and bang on the door.
When it became evident that neither of those actions was going to solve my problem, I realized that I had entered the territory where bitachon mattered more than hishtadlut.
The principle here was neatly expressed by Rabbi Yisrael Salanter in the 19th century Mussar movement. According to Rav Yisrael, your mind must fully commit to using the natural means at its disposal – punch in the code, bang on the door – as if your survival depended entirely on that. But if it comes to the point that those options are exhausted or fail to yield a result, you have to be ready to shift your inner reality completely to bitachon – trusting that what is at play here is bigger than the field you control, putting you in God’s territory.
As he put it:
A person needs to have bitachon as if there is no hishtadlus, and at the same time, one needs to do hishtadlus as if there is no bitachon.
I have some thoughts on how this works in practice.
The book Chovot Ha’Levavot [Duties of the Heart] is the fundamental source for teachings on bitachon. Written in Judeo-Arabic and first published in Spain in the year 1080, this book from nearly 1,000 years ago contains ten sections, one of which is given over to teachings on the inner trait of trusting God.
Of all the teachings in all the chapters of that section, the one that is quoted the most often tells us that the benefit a person gets from trusting God is menuchat ha’nefesh, which translates literally as the repose or tranquility of the soul. What this is pointing to is an inner state of calm, serenity, and freedom from agitation.
It makes sense. If you really trust in God, then why would you be emotionally unsettled by anxieties, frustrations, desires or the circumstances that confront you at any point in your life? Trust is the antidote to worry. The door may be locked, but who can say with certainty that a worse fate awaits than if the door had swung open? How did the door come to be double-locked in the first place? What if a violent fugitive had taken shelter inside? And isn’t it conceivable that because I had been turned away from that door, I would head in another direction and maybe that would cause me to cross paths with someone I would otherwise never have met, who was carrying a gem that had come into the world just for me?
I am reminded of the story about the family of the Mussar teacher, Rabbi Yehudah Leib Nekritz, which included his daughter Shoshana, the future wife of my own Mussar teacher, Rabbi Yechiel Yitzchok Perr, Near the beginning of World War II, the Nekritz family was exiled from Poland to Siberia. The Russians had invaded the part of Poland where they lived, and because Rabbi Nekritz had been born in Russia, he was judged suspicious and so was sent to labour in the harsh north country. Of course, everyone in the town was distraught for the poor Nekritz family, since all the others were allowed to remain at home while this one family was singled out for the punishment of exile. “Terrible, terrible,” they moaned, and it was indeed terrible, except for the fact that remaining in the town ultimately turned out to be an even worse fate, once the Nazis rolled into that part of Poland and consigned all the Jews who lived there to the death camps.
At the end of the war, the Nekritz family was released and made their way to the United States. The exile to Siberia had been their ticket to survival.
The 16th century text, Orchot Tzaddikim (Pathways of the Righteous) in the section dealing with worry says that a person who trusts in God does not worry. To the contrary. While there is no chapter in this book that is devoted to bitachon, the discussion of that inner trait shows up where? In the Gate of Joy! Worry over attaining anything in this world “is not found at all in those who trust and believe in God.” But joy is.
Tranquility of the soul is a deep, pervasive, reassuring sense of trust that suffuses the inner being down to the cellular level. It transcends conscious thought, though it is not separate from it. In fact, the Mussar teachers tell us that one significant thing about “tranquility of the soul” that makes it a desirable inner state is that it has a direct effect on our thought processes.
A soul in repose (i.e., with menuchat ha’nefesh) ushers in the inner quality known as yeshuv ha’da’at, literally meaning “settling of the mind.” What we are talking about here is mental composure, clarity, sound judgment, and the capacity to think without confusion or impulsiveness.
Bitachon gives rise to menuchat hanefesh and menuchat hanefesh yields yishuv ha’da’at. In English that says that trust in God gives rise to repose of the soul, and that in turn, yields a settled mind.
It seems incontestable that having a settled mind was the key to getting me out of my predicament. At the point that punching the keypad and pounding on the door failed, all I had to work with was my mind. Had I panicked, had I given myself over to fear or worry or any other overwhelming emotional response, that is sure to have compromised my ability to consider matters thoughtfully, to figure out what was important, and to respond rather than react.
Access to memory and clear thinking enabled me to remember my host’s names, where they lived, the landmark at the end of their street, the look of their block of flats, and the number of their apartment. Once I had used my capacities to land up in their apartment, at that point, help started to arrive. Now I wasn’t thinking my way through the problems. Now it was the woman who knew the phone number of the former rabbi of the synagogue, and the current rabbi who answered his phone, and the landlord who was not on vacation out of the country, and my friend who found the right lockbox that contained the needed key.
I am thinking that maybe my experience fits within the paradigm we learn from the Torah’s story about Nachshon ben Aminadav. When Pharaoh finally let the people go, and the Jews had come to the Red Sea with the Egyptians right behind them in hot pursuit, they found themselves trapped between the water and the approaching army. At that moment, Nachshon stepped into the water, first up to his ankles, then his knees, then his body until he was submerged right up to his nose. Only then did the sea split.
This model seems to fit my story. Heaven came to my rescue – especially through the agency of the dinner guest who miraculously knew the phone number of the former rabbi of the synagogue who gave me the number of the current rabbi – but none of that happened until I had first exhausted the practical means I had at my disposal. I had to wade into the water up to my nose. Having done that and having leaned into my embedded sense of trust in God, my mind settled and I was able to think clearly. That, in turn, set the stage for the inflow of assistance that reunited me with my cell phone, my passport and my toothbrush.
Is that a good explanation? Where are the holes? How might you improve on it?


